Film Review: BEFORE WE VANISH (Japan 2017)

Submit your Screenplay to the Festival TODAY

Before We Vanish Poster
Three aliens travel to Earth in preparation for a mass invasion, taking possession of human bodies.


Kiyoshi Kurosawa


Tomohiro Maekawa (based on the play by),Kiyoshi Kurosawa (screenplay) | 1 more credit »


Before watching BEFORE WE VANISH or reading this review of BEFORE WE VANISH, it is best that a bit of background be known of the film’s director, Kiyoshi Kurosawa.

Kiyoshi Kurosawa is better known in North America as an art-house horror director with films like CURE and PULSE both of which I have seen but have not praised.  His best film to date is PENANCE, made for Japanese TV but screened here at the Toronto International Film Festival  and also played at Cannes which won Kurosawa the Best Director Award in the Un Certain Regard Section at Cannes.  Korosawa’s latest, BEFORE WE VANISH (Sanpo suru shinryakusha), is a sci-fi thriller that also serves as a story about the redemptive power of love, played at Cannes 2017 in the Un Certain Regard sidebar.  Not his best film, but interesting, nevertheless.  It should be noted that the film is based on the play by Tomoshiro Maekawa, and co-written with Sachiko Tanaka.

There are strange goings-on in an otherwise ordinary Japanese town.  While investigating a gruesome murder, journalist Sakurai (Hiroki Hasegawa) meets two aliens (Yuri Tsunematsu and Mahiro Takasugi) who have taken up residence in human hosts.  Preparing for a takeover of the planet, the aliens are not only snatching bodies, but also robbing humans of values (family, 

work, good, evil, etc.), leaving only hollow shells, all but unrecognizable to their loved ones.  Meanwhile a third alien has taken over a man named Shinji Ryuhei Matsuda).  After disappearing for several days, Shinji reappears, acting nothing like his former self.  His marriage to Narumi had been on the rocks.  But Shinji seems kinder now.  As chaos ensues, Sakurai and 

Narumi each must make a decision.  Narumi’s, in particular, is heartbreaking.

Interesting though the premise might seem, bringing down an alien invasion down to the personal level, the film has major problems, primarily in the credibility of its story.  The invasion is supposed to take place, masterminded by just three aliens who have taken over human bodies.  Two of them need to find the third, Shinji for success.  The conception idea is a good one, when aliens absorb a human concept from a human.  But the film’s climax is silly and gets worse when the film concludes to a period of two years after the conclusion, when reverse conception takes place.  The film runs into even more problems when Kurosawa brings in human values to save the world.  Kusrosawa turns too preachy as well with a sermon on love: “Love never records wrongs; love never gets angry… etc.”

As talented as Kurosawa is and as good as his best films are, BEFORE WE VANISH is a major disappointment.  Silly even from the very start from the way aliens inhabits bodies or captures conception, the premise might have succeeded in an artsy play, as is the source material, but moviegoers expect certain rules to be followed in a sci-fi alien invasion thriller.  



Submit your Screenplay to the Festival TODAY

TIFF 2016 Movie Review: DAGUERROTYPE (LE SECRET DE LA CHAMBE NOIRE) (France/Belgium/Japan 2016)

Movie Reviews of films that will be playing at TIFF (Toronto International Film Festival) in 2016. Go to TIFF 2016 Movie Reviews and read reviews of films showing at the festival.

daguerrotype_poster.jpgDAGUERROTYPE (LE SECRET DE LA CHAMBE NOIRE) (France/Belgium/Japan 2016) **
Directed by Kiyoshi Kurosawa

Starring: Tahar Rahim, Constance Rousseau, Olivier Gourmet

Review by Gilbert Seah

Non French directors often do not translate well when making a French film. The latest casualty is Japanese director Kiyoshi Kurosaw (TOKYO SONATA, CURE). His latest film is a ghost story, a genre that Kurosawa is already familiar with. He is blessed with some great French speaking talent including Tahir Rahim (UN PROPHET, UNE SEPARATION), Matthieu Amalric and Olivier Gourmet.

Gourmet plays a photographer who after the suicide of his wife becomes obsessed with her portrait being able to live forever. His obsession turns towards his daughter and soon, his new assistant (Rahim) also falls for the apparition.

The story is not well told with bouts of reality and fantasy flowing into each other uncomfortably. Kurosawa loves filming trains, and again the TGV trains are shown in the opening segment. If only his film would run as fast.

The film is a slow burning process with an unsatisfying and open ending.

Free logline submissions. The Writing Festival network averages over 95,000 unique visitors a day.

Great way to get your story out:

Deadlines to Submit your Screenplay, Novel, Story, or Poem to the festival:

Watch recent Writing Festival Videos. At least 15 winning videos a month: