Jonathan Lethem (based on the novel by), Edward Norton (screenplay)
Acclaimed actor Edward Norton returns to the director’s chair (this is his second directorial effort) with his passionate MOTHERLESS BROOKLYN based on the book which he read way back when, when he was starring in AMERICAN HISTORY X. It was his long time goal to bring it to the screen and this 140 minute effort often displays his passion in the making of it. Though by no means flawless, the 140-minute long haul moves pretty fast, thanks to the strength of the film’s source, the multiple award winning 1999 novel by Jonathan Lethem of the same name.
Norton who also penned the script made several changes to the book. As he thought the film’s theme lent to more of a noir setting, he moved the 1999 modern setting to a 1959 one, move obviously requiring greater effort in filmmaking, because of not only period atmosphere, pros and sets. but in dialogue as well. The cinematography by Mike Leigh’s favourite, Oscar nominated Dick Pope is to be commended. His best scene is the one where the water on the sidewalk reflects a beautiful picture similar to the one where the refection of water reflects a plane flying overhead in Alfonso Cuaron’s ROMA.
The film follows a private investigator with Tourette’s syndrome, Lionel Essrog nicknamed MOTHERLESS BROOKLYN (played by Norton himself) who must solve the murder of his mentor. Lionel Essrog, has Tourette’s, a disorder marked by involuntary tics. Essrog works for Frank Minna (Bruce Willis), a small-time neighbourhood owner of a “seedy and makeshift” detective agency, who is shot (stabbed to death in the novel) to death. Together, Essrog and three other characters—Tony, Danny, and Gilbert— solve the case. The reason for the deduction is that Frank looked after these 4 in the orphanage when they were kids.
It is best to know about the Tourette’s (tics) syndrome as the protagonist has the affliction and director/actor Norton makes sure his audience does not forget it. It is a nerve disorder with onset in childhood, characterized by multiple motor tics and at least one vocal (phonic) tic. These tics characteristically wax and wane, can be suppressed temporarily, and are typically preceded by an unwanted urge or sensation in the affected muscles. Some common tics are eye blinking, coughing, throat clearing, sniffing, and facial movements. Tourette’s does not adversely affect intelligence or life expectancy. In the film, Lionel is supposed to have heightened memory capabilities because of the syndrome. Another fact is that adults suffering from this syndrome is a rarity, as they go away with adolescence.
The draw of he story is both the solving of the murder and the subplot involving the corruption of power. Norton introduces the new character of Moses Randolph (Alec Baldwin) a city planner who is so obsessed with port ta he would do anything to gain it. Baldwin has a field day with this role, that includes a long speech of what power is, and what it can do for people and how he craves and has it. No one can stop me…. he boasts. All this brings the more reason for Lionel to take the man down.
Because of the setting, the film looks and borrows from Roman Polanski’s CHINATOWN though understandably never reaching the heights of that classic. But MOTHERLESS BROOKLYN is a totally enjoyable watch, with Norton giving full respect to his source material while never downplaying the syndrome for cheap laughs, but offering his audience intelligent look at the rare disease.